Randomized controlled trials have greatly expanded in the last two decades randomized controlled trials were progressively accepted as a tool for policy evaluation in the us through many battles from the 1970s to the 1990s. Abstract objectives to assess the efficacy and safety of hydroxychloroquine hcq plus standardofcare soc compared with soc alone in adult patients with covid19. This work is licensed under a creative commons attribution. We study the properties of imbalances tests of predetermined characteristics covariates in stratified randomized controlled trials. The case for randomized field trials in economic and policy research 67 whether it is ethical, useful, or costeffective to carry out such experiments on humans is a matter of debate.
Question is there evidence that response to antidepressants varies systematically based on individual differences findings in a metaanalysis of 87 randomized clinical trials 17 540 unique participants on the use of antidepressants in individuals with major depression, there was 14% more variability in response to antidepressants than to placebo. Understanding and misunderstanding randomized controlled trials angus deaton, nancy cartwright. Randomized controlled trials are one of the most powerful and revolutionary tools of research. Starting in 1994, glewwe, kremer, and moulin 2009 kickstarted the use of. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. We assess evidence from randomized control trials rcts on longrun economic productivity and living standards in poor countries. I had the pleasure of discussing along with martin ravallion esther duflos talk on the influence of randomized controlled trials on development economics research and on development policy. Bias, randomization, rcts, study design alex eble corresponding author is assistant professor of economics and education at teachers college. Ricardo hausmann director, center for international development. The influence of randomized controlled trials on development economics research and on development policy 2 about twenty years ago, the idea of randomized controlled trials was just starting to make its way into development economics. Design multicenter, openlabel, randomized controlled trial. Though the first parallel group study ostensibly dates to prechristian times as discussed in section i. A toolkit this paper is a practical guide a toolkit for researchers, students and practitioners wishing to introduce randomization as part of a research design in the field.
This work is licensed under a creative commons attributionnoncommercialsharealike license. A randomized controlled trial is one of the best ways of keeping the bias of the researchers out of the data and making sure that a study gives the fairest representation of a drugs safety and. Randomized controlled trials, development economics and. Collier 2009 so we provide only a brief discussion of their development to motivate our analysis. We start by discussing the three contributions highlighted in the introduction. Should the randomistas center for global development. The purpose of the report is to describe the method and to provide an overview of under what. Deaton randomization revisited v2 2019 princeton university. Randomized controlled trials sage research methods. Instruments, randomization, and learning about development.
Before approval of a new drug, the us food and drug administration fda requires phase 3 clinical trials demonstrating efficacy. Using randomized controlled trials to estimate longrun impacts. The influence of randomized controlled trials on development economics research and on development policy. Impact evaluation based on randomized controlled trials rcts offers a powerful.
Using rcts to estimate longrun impacts in development. The study of development concerns human beings as agents whose choices. The case for randomized field trials in economic and. There is skepticism about the ability of econometric analysis to resolve these issues or of development agencies to learn from their own experience.
Randomized controlled trials rcts page 2 in a simple rct, the unit of analysis for the intervention and for the random assignment is the same. Using randomization in development economics research. We conclude that the rise of development economics rcts. Randomized controlled trials often suffer from two major complications, i. Randomized controlled trials in radiology can play a major role in the assessment of screening programs, diagnostic tests, and procedures in interventional radiology 6. Randomistas, proponents of randomized controlled trials, have recently been transforming the way we think about economic development and aid to poor countries. Using randomized controlled trials to estimate longrun. Perspectives on randomized trials in development economics, by t. In the united states, more than 50% of people with chronic conditions have 2 or more diseases. A man walks past buildings at the central business district of singapore.
On the analogy between field experiments in economics and. Individual differences in response to antidepressants. Structured in a jargonfree questionandanswer format, each chapter provides concise and understandable information. No other study design gives us the power to balance unknown. The current boom in randomised trials in development economics, in contrast, has almost entirely involved experimentation on poor persons in poor countries.
For example, when evaluating a programme that provides nutrition to individuals, individuals might be randomly assigned to receive nutritional supplements. An important advance in this field has been the development of an assessment method, known as randomized controlled trialrct. Banerjee, abhijit, esther duflo, and michael kremer. Usually trials are conducted in homogeneous populations and rarely include individuals with multiple chronic conditions. Consideration of multiple chronic diseases in randomized. Instruments, randomization, and learning about development 427 heckman 1992 and heckman and jeffrey a. It first covers the rationale for the use of randomization, as a. In development, the rapid growth starts after the mid 1990s kremer et al, studies on kenya 1994.
We next present evidence from a systematic survey of existing rcts, with a focus on cash. The critical element that distinguishes controlled experiments from all other methods of research is the random assignment of meaningfully different. Trials in medicine and economics the history of randomized trials is well documented elsewhere, meldrum 2000. Development of methods to go beyond simple comparison of. The power and pitfalls of experiments in development economics. A guide to incorporating multiple methods in randomized. Randomization, if done properly, can keep study groups as similar as possible at the outset, so that the investigators can isolate and quantify the effect of the interventions they are studying. One potential solution to this problem is a statistical concept called intentiontotreat itt analysis. Understanding and misunderstanding randomized controlled. Poor economics, randomized controlled trials rcts, mit poverty lab, abhijit banerjee. Randomized controlled trials cannot yield robust data unless they are planned, conducted, and analyzed in ways that are methodologically sound and appropriate to the question being asked. Program on the economics of aging, development economics program, health care program, health economics program, labor studies program. The influence of randomized controlled trials on development economics research and development policy the state of economics, the state of the world, 2019, edited by kaushik basu, david rosenblatt and claudia sepulveda, mit.
On minimizing the risk of bias in randomized controlled trials in economics alex eble, peter boone, and diana elbourne jel codes. The trials help build and test theory and theory in turn can answer questions about new settings and populations that we cannot answer by simple extrapolation or generalization of the trial results. Balancing tests in stratified randomized controlled trials. A randomized controlled trial rct is an experimental form of impact evaluation in which the population receiving the programme or policy. We conclude that the rise of development economics rcts since roughly. A randomized controlled trial is a prospective, comparative, quantitative study experiment performed under controlled conditions with random allocation of interventions to comparison groups. Economists have been combining theory and randomized controlled trials in a variety of other ways since the early experiments.
While rcts have a place in the toolkit for impact evaluation, an unconditional preference for rcts as the gold standard is questionable. When the parameter of interest is a weighted average of the causal effects at all strata, then a test statistic based on a fixed effects regression model may suffice to detect the relevant imbalances. Setting 16 governmentdesignated covid19 treatment centers in china through 11 to 29 in february 2020. This paper was previously circulated under the title risk and evidence of bias in randomized controlled trials in. On minimizing the risk of bias in randomized controlled. Randomized controlled trials it is mainly in the last 35 to 40 years, determined efforts have been made to use scientific techniques to evaluate methods of treatment and prevention. The language in the manual uses many of the concepts necessary for. We first document that several studies estimate large positive longrun impacts, but that relatively few existing rcts have been evaluated over the long run. Jeffrey hammer outlines three concerns about the use of randomized control trials, rather than the importance and relevance of the policy question, is the basis of evidence for guiding development.
Randomized controlled trials, development economics and policy. Cep discussion paper no 1240 september 20 risk and. In response, there is increasing use in development economics of randomized controlled trials rcts to accumulate credible knowl. The main appeal of the randomized controlled trial rct in health care comes from its potential to reduce selection bias. Randomized controlled trials are used to examine the effect of interventions on particular outcomes such as death or the recurrence of disease. The modern approach to development economics relies on two simple but powerful.
Perspectives on randomized trials in development economics, tim ogden has assembled interviews with a distinguished group that interacts with rcts in every imaginable way this collection provides great insight into many of the great minds of those producing and using development economics in our. Financial ties of principal investigators and randomized. Development economists have been using randomized controlled trials rcts for. Randomized controlled trials science is concerned with understanding variability in nature, statistics is concerned with making decisions about nature in the presence of variability, and experimental design is concerned with. Natural experiments think of rct as a natural benchmark not just an hypothetical gold standard. The challenge of doing development economics, and doing it well. Using rcts to estimate longrun impacts in development economics adrien bouguen, yue huang, michael kremer, edward miguel.
Economics is an open subject in the sense that good studies that. Although the buzz around rct evaluations dates from the 2000s, we show that what we are witnessing now is a second wave of rcts, while a first wave began in the. This book is a convenient and accessible description of the underlying principles and practice of randomized controlled trials and their role in clinical decisionmaking. The authors, already very well known for their earlier work promoting the use of randomized controlled trials in empirical development economics, use this method to shed light on many controversies that often rage with little or, even worse, misleading factual support. We assess evidence from randomized controlled trials rcts on longrun economic productivity and living standards in poor countries. The rising popularity of randomized controlled trials rcts in development applications has come with continuing debates on the pros and cons of this approach. Understanding and misunderstanding randomized controlled trials angus deaton and nancy cartwright princeton university durham university and uc san diego this version, august 2016 we acknowledge helpful discussions with many people over.
Pdf we assess evidence from randomized control trials rcts on longrun economic productivity and living standards in poor countries. Children, development economics, health economics we assess evidence from randomized control trials rcts on longrun economic productivity and living. Then, we briefly discuss the main empirical method. We next present evidence from a systematic survey of existing rcts, with a focus on cash transfer and.
We assess evidence from randomized controlled trials rcts on longrun. Rct requires solid baseline studies and welldefined objectives, the. The state of economics, the state of the world conference at the world bank. Objective to examine the association between the presence of individual principal investigators financial ties to the manufacturer of the study drug and the trials outcomes after accounting for source of research funding design cross sectional study of randomized controlled trials rcts setting studies published in core clinical journals, as. Pdf chapter 3 bias in randomized controlled trials. Should economists think again before using randomized control trials. This article brings a historical perspective to explain the recent dissemination of randomized controlled trials rcts as the new gold standard method to assess international development projects. Should economists think again before using randomized. In clinical research, randomized controlled trials are the gold standard for demonstrating the efficacy and safety of a new treatment. Itt analysis includes every subject who is randomized according to randomized treatment assignment.
1236 612 1358 1475 1084 169 490 1191 1157 1448 1327 589 1148 477 1388 345 778 1127 217 164 286 1406 559 933 664 600 982 1496 1424 407 56